Your Beermonger: Gearing up for Thanksgiving

by ARLnow.com November 16, 2012 at 1:35 pm 3,386 22 Comments

Editor’s Note: This sponsored column is written by Nick Anderson, beermonger at Arrowine (4508 Lee Highway)

Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday of the year. A whole day dedicated to hanging out with people you love, eating amazing food, and a beverage or three? Oh yes, I am a Thanksgiving guy. Thanksgiving is also the busiest time of year for folks in my business, with most people coming by the store looking for advice on what to serve their guests for the holiday.

Picking out the right beers to enjoy and serve your guests at Thanksgiving is not all that dissimilar to working out wine pairings for the holiday. In some ways, it can actually be much easier. Here are a couple of tips for selecting your beers for the Thanksgiving table, and a couple of suggestions that I think will work well:

Don’t over-think it: This is a trap I used to fall into regularly when choosing wine for Thanksgiving, or any meal for that matter. You want so badly to find the perfect match; to blow everyone at the table away with your harmony of food and beverage. We all want to be seen as gurus of all things food and wine (and beer), especially during the food holiday.

The problem comes when we take time to consider the insane spectrum of flavors, textures, levels of sweetness, etc. in the dishes seen in the average Thanksgiving spread. What if the bacon in the green bean dish is a tick charred? What if Aunt Jenny brings that thing with the marshmallows and pretzels again? What herbs will be used with the turkey?

There are a million variables with Thanksgiving dinner, and unless you’re obsessively planning every aspect of the meal (not that some of us aren’t) it is nigh impossible to 100% nail it with either a wine or a beer pairing. Take the time to consider, but realize that there is likely a point where you’ve done the best you can. If you hit a wall, find something you know will work for the most part and is easily enjoyable.

This brings me to the next tip:

Know your audience: I brought a really nice bottle of wine to my family’s Thanksgiving get-together once. Once. The Barolo I thought was safe in a decanter in the dining room while everything was being prepared ended up being consumed hours before it was ready, let alone before dinner was. You have to bear in mind the level of appreciation that your folks have for these things: there’s nothing inherently wrong with dropping a couple ice cubes in your glass of White Zinfandel (tastes being subjective and all), but it should be a heads up to you that Grand Cru Pinot Noir from Burgundy may be bringing a cannon to a knife fight.

Finding a balance between food-pairing ability and pure enjoyment is the key for Thanksgiving.  Some thought to how a beverage will match up is smart and encouraged, but have a care for the experience levels of those around you. I’ve come around to a “keep it simple, stupid” way of thinking for the most part, where I want to play to the broader palate. As always, your mileage may vary. Here are some beers I think would work at your Thanksgiving table:

Schlafly Kolsch: With a smooth, clean mouthfeel not unlike a classic Lager and the bright, fruity notes of an Ale, Schlafly’s Kolsch is the definition of everything I’ve talked about in this column. If you’re looking for a beer with broad appeal that can play off of various dishes, Schalfly Kolsch merits serious consideration.

Maine Beer Co. Peeper Pale Ale: A recent arrival to our area, Maine Beer Company is a small outfit making some extraordinary beers. The hops in Peeper Pale emphasize clarity rather than aggressiveness, and a fine carbonation accentuates this Pale Ale’s refreshing nature. An elegant way to get your hop fix this holiday.

Stillwater Autumnal: This one’s a bit of a dark horse as it may be hard to find, but I think this beer makes a ton of sense for Thanksgiving. Essential an Oktoberfest recipe, Brian Strumke ferments Autumnal with his farmhouse yeast strain to create a smooth, malty Ale (rather than a Lager as a traditional Oktoberfest would be) with fruit and spice notes from the yeast. There is just enough sweetness for Autumnal to handle sweet potato casserole, but crisp and complex enough to play with turkey and stuffing.

Bell’s Christmas Ale: Why not get fully into the season? As Scotch-style Ales go, Bell’s Christmas is pretty mild, but I think that makes it great for Thanksgiving. As a crisper take on a malty style, Bell’s Christmas has hints of caramel and roasty malts that make for a versatile food-pairing Ale. Stock up for the season: this one goes really well with a nice honey-glazed ham at Christmas.

Evil Twin The Cowboy: For those feeling a tad adventurous, this Smoked Pilsner may be just the thing. The smoked malts aren’t overpowering and the use of Pilsner as the base gives everyone a familiar touchstone. All in all, The Cowboy is an oddity that doesn’t come across as being all that odd and should be immensely enjoyable at the Thanksgiving table.

The Bruery Autumn Maple: Hard to find as most stores have sold out already, but there’s nothing else I want when dessert starts coming out on Thanksgiving. The notes from the yam, maple syrup, molasses, and spices in Autumn Maple are flat-out perfect for serving alongside pumpkin or pecan pie (I’m a pecan guy, myself).

No matter what you serve, I hope you have a great Thanksgiving at a table lined with great friends and family. I’ll see you next week with a holiday shopping list for the beer geek in your life.


Nick Anderson maintains a blog at www.beermonger.net, and can be found on Twitter at @The_Beermonger. Sign up for Arrowine’s money saving email offers and free wine and beer tastings at www.arrowine.com/mailing-list-signup.aspx. The views and opinions expressed in the column are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of ARLnow.com.

Community discussion guidelines: Our sponsored columns are written by members of the local business community. While we encourage a robust and open discussion, we ask that all reviews of the businesses — good or bad — be directed to another venue, like Yelp. The comments section is intended for a conversation about the topic of the article.

  • RS

    I’ve always been partial to Allagash’s Curieux Ale for Thanksgiving dinner…or any holiday dinner, really.

    The smokiness and bourbon flavor from the barrel aging goes great with turkey. Also, the hints of vanilla and subtle sweetness pairs well with sweet potatoes, pumpkin and other season flavors.

    It’s also ridiculously potent at 11% ABV, which makes your family increasingly tolerable as the contents of the bottle make their way into your belly.

    Check it out: http://www.allagash.com/beer/year-round/curieux

    • TheBeermonger

      Great beer that could lead to some serious holiday fun.

  • blah

    I think Lagunitas Brown Shugga would be a great after dinner before pie beer.

  • bert

    Don’t over think it. That really is the best advice when it comes down to it.

    If anyone wants some Southern Tier Pumking let me know, I’ve got a few cases I’d be willing to sell at a fair price. It’s become my favorite Thanksgiving/Fall beer, but I have a lot.

    • finger11

      Interested… what’s your e-mail?

  • Venn Diagram

    Don’t forget about the semi-rare Hobopee™ – I believe there are only about a dozen bottles of this available down near Pentagon City. Not terribly pricey and has a real unique bouquet.

    • TheBeermonger

      Damn you for trademarking this.

  • 14 years in the Arbor and counting

    Thanksgiving with the relatives causes me to drink heavily.

    • TheBeermonger

      Why I don’t do it anymore.

  • Hal

    I like a nice, warming Maudite during the holidays. The legend it refers to is appropriate too, though if your family is like mine, the alcohol content is high enough you can pretend you’re being transported *away* from them in a magical flying canoe instead.

  • Aaron

    Faithfull Ale went over really well with the family last year. If I can’t lay hands on a couple of Wisconsin Belgian Reds in time, I think Trader Joe’s Vintage Ale will get the call up this year.

  • John Fontain

    “The problem comes when we take time to consider the insane spectrum of flavors, textures, levels of sweetness, etc. in the dishes seen in the average Thanksgiving spread. What if the bacon in the green bean dish is a tick charred?”

    I don’t mean to sound ungrateful for the info in this series of articles, but reading stuff like this makes me wonder: What would the many people in this country who are just trying to keep a roof over their head and hopefully keep their kids from going hungry tonight think if they read this?

    • bert

      you could say that any day and any where in this world.

      • TheBeermonger

        Yup. Until the column is changed to “Your Fix-the-worldmonger”, I gotta do what I do. And unfortunately, to your chagrin, that includes giving advice that often is in response to questions just like this.

        Anyone who wants to spend their holiday helping those in need gets all the respect in the world from me. Sitting in judgement of those who want to provide the best experience they can to the friends and family around their table? That’s something else.

        • John Fontain

          “Sitting in judgement of those who want to provide the best experience they can to the friends and family around their table?”

          My comment pertained to the writing in your column, not to those who want to provide a nice meal for their family.

  • Chris

    As long as you don’t forget to have a sour in there somewhere, you’ll be fine.

    • TheBeermonger

      As much as I love them, Sours are not the way to go at Thanksgiving.

  • Malaka

    My favorie beert for this time of year is Victory Moonglow Weizenbock – but it seems to have passed us by this year…?

    • TheBeermonger

      Either that or it’s running late. Seen reports of it in other markets. I do enjoy Moonglow, but haven’t heard of it arriving here yet.

      • Drew

        Any good sours in stock?

  • bounds of pretense

    I think you just pushed them pretty far yourself johnny boy


Subscribe to our mailing list