Join Club

NOVA Legal Beat: Unfair Unsatisfactory Rating?

NOVA Legal Beat logo

Editor’s Note: This sponsored column is written by Mathew B. Tully of Tully Rinckey PLLC, an Arlington firm that specializes in federal employment and labor law, security clearance proceedings, and military law.

Q. Can my agency give me an unsatisfactory performance rating because I messed up on one thing during the entire year?

A. A federal agency’s one-strike-you’re-out policy, when applied to a performance appraisal system, is generally known as an “absolute performance standard.” The Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB), as it stated in Juanita M. Blain v. Department of Veterans Affairs (1988), has traditionally viewed absolute performance standards as providing that “only one incident of poor performance would result in an unsatisfactory rating on a job element.”

Up until about a decade ago, the Board had believed statute prohibited absolute performance standards, except in cases “where death, injury, breach of security, or great monetary loss could result from a single failure to meet the performance standard measuring performance of a single critical element.” That changed when its appellate court, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, in Cynthia A. Guillebeau v. Department of the Navy (2004) ruled that statute does not actually prohibit the adoption of such high standards.

Federal law calls for performance appraisal systems that “to the maximum extent feasible, permit the accurate evaluation of job performance on the basis of objective criteria… related to the job in question for each employee or position under the system.”

Even though the law does not ban absolute performance standards, the Federal Circuit pointed out that such standards must be “must be reasonable, based on objective criteria, and communicated to the employee in advance.” An example of an unreasonable performance standard identified by the court was a standard “permitting so few errors in pulling medical records from files that, based upon the number of records the employee is required to pull, the employee must be at least 99.91% accurate.”

Federal employees who believe their agency’s performance appraisal system includes unreasonable performance standards should immediately contact a federal employment law attorney who can help them file a grievance or complaint challenging the validity of their performance ratings and standards.

Mathew B. Tully is the founding partner of Tully Rinckey PLLC. Located in Arlington, Va. and Washington, D.C., Tully Rinckey PLLC’s attorneys practice criminal defense, matrimonial and family law, federal employment law, and military law. To speak with an attorney, call 703-525-4700 or to learn more visit

The views and opinions expressed in the column are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of

Recent Stories

A fundraiser for Commonwealth’s Attorney candidate Josh Katcher has drawn some notable local names. Katcher is running in June’s Democratic primary to unseat his former boss, Parisa Dehghani-Tafti, as Arlington’s…

Taoiseach Leo Varadkar, the prime minister of Ireland, took in a history-making rugby match at a bar in Pentagon City over the weekend. Varadkar watched the Ireland claim the Guinness…

Morning Notes

More on Rock Creek Park Crash Victims — “A Lyft driver and his two passengers were the men killed in a crash with an SUV that had just fled a…

Truly, it’s the most wonderful time of the year, and I am not talking about St. Patrick’s Day, the start of Daylight Savings, or even the cherry blossoms. It’s the…

The March NAACP Arlington Branch General Membership Meeting

The March NAACP Arlington Branch General Membership Meeting is focused on Public Safety & Justice. We will hear from Commonwealth’s Attorney Parisa Dehghani-Tafti, Chief Public Defender Brad Haywood, Chief of Police Andy Penn, and Deputy Chief Wayne Vincent. We encourage you to come to this community conversation prepared with questions for our speakers. Registration Required

Guest Speakers

Read More

Submit your own Announcement here.

Too many of us in our community have experienced wrenching loss lately. It can be particularly tricky to navigate as Spring arrives. While it may feel like the very last thing you are able to do, we urge you to consider a local support group and we have a list of a few that our clients have found to be welcoming and healing. This is by no means a complete list, but from Capital Caring to Haven of Northern Virginia to the Wendt Center to the Dinner Party you will find people who get what you are going through.

Submit your own Announcement here.

5 Tips for Buying Your Dream Home – A Free…

Are you planning to move in the next 12 months but feeling overwhelmed by the current real estate market’s low inventory and high mortgage rates? Join us for a short seminar where we’ll provide 5 tips to help you find

Free Ice Cream at Nicecream

Locally owned ice cream shop, Nicecream, is celebrating their freezing agent liquid nitrogen (-321°F), Nicecream is offering unlimited, free ice cream all day on March 21st.

On Tuesday March 21, 2023 Nicecream will give out unlimited free ice cream to


Subscribe to our mailing list