JUST IN: Youngkin vetoes Arlington police auditor bill

(Updated at 1:55 p.m.) Gov. Glenn Youngkin’s first veto could mean Arlington’s police oversight board cannot be led by an independent policing auditor.

Today (Tuesday), the Republican governor vetoed his first bill: HB 670, put forward by Arlington’s Del. Patrick Hope (D). It would have granted the Arlington County Board permission to appoint an independent auditor who would oversee the Community Oversight Board (COB), which is tasked with handling civilian complaints of misconduct by Arlington police officers.

Arlington County Board Chair Katie Cristol told ARLnow this morning that the Board wants to work with Youngkin to clarify the powers of the county’s police oversight board and the role of the auditor in hopes that he will rescind the veto.

The Arlington County Democratic Committee decried the veto as “play[ing] politics with a commonsense measure that passed the GOP controlled House.”

Vetoing Arlington

Despite passing with bipartisan support Governor Youngkin vetoed a bill from @HopeforVirginia that would have allowed an independent police auditor in Arlington

There is no reason to play politics with a commonsense measure that passed the GOP controlled House https://t.co/9TSNf4Tlpr

— Arlington Democrats (@arlingtondems) March 1, 2022

The policing auditor would have been a County Board-appointed position and the person filling the role would have answered directly to the Board. Most other top managerial positions report to the Board-appointed County Manager.

Should Youngkin’s veto remain in place, Cristol says the COB would still be led by an auditor, but this leader would instead answer to County Manager Mark Schwartz. That would mean a weaker auditor, she adds.

“It was really important that the independent policing auditor be just that, and not be under the chief law enforcement official of the county, which is the County Manager,” Cristol said.

Cristol says the Board wants to work with Youngkin because it seems — by his press release — that he misunderstands what the COB can and cannot do. She said the governor may have vetoed the bill based on a faulty understanding of the new body’s powers.

“Based on his press release, I think he made this action without full knowledge of what he was vetoing,” she said. “Specifically, he says, in referencing his vetoing of the bill, the Community Oversight Board would ‘make binding disciplinary determinations, including termination and involuntary restitution.’ Our ordinance didn’t empower the COB or the independent auditor to do that.”

Hope’s bill was merely an “administrative fix” to a bill passed last year, she said.

“Assuming this does stand, we are incredibly disappointed,” she said. “It’s not an expansion of [the] Community Oversight Board in the Commonwealth. It puts Arlington into parity with other jurisdictions in the Commonwealth.”

Del. Hope explains that his bill corrects for a shortcoming in the county charter that requires the County Board to get permission from the General Assembly to make any hire. He says Youngkin’s response is a new one.

“In my 13 years of service, I don’t ever recall seeing a Governor vetoing a local Charter bill,” he said. “To say that I’m disappointed the Governor would use his veto pen on a Charter bill to make a misguided political statement is an understatement.”

Hope says the County Manager can still make the hire after Youngkin’s veto.

“And the Governor’s veto will not do anything related to disciplinary powers of the policing oversight body,” he said. “That authority rests solely in the ordinance and has nothing to do with this position.”

Arlington’s Community Oversight Board was created last summer, after the state passed legislation allowing jurisdictions to establish such entities. The county is currently selecting members.

Both the COB and the independent auditor-monitor were recommendations from the Police Practices Group, convened after 2020’s summer of nationwide racial justice protests. The Board endowed the COB with the power to subpoena for evidence or witnesses if the police department withholds them.

The veto “takes shots” at Arlington residents who shaped the COB as well as a measure with broad support from residents, the Virginia State Conference NAACP and both Republican and Democrat legislators, says the Arlington NAACP.

“This is not governance,” said Arlington NAACP president Julius “J.D.” Spain, Sr. “It is the exercise of raw political power to the detriment of our community and marginalized communities who have been disproportionately affected by improper policing for decades. With this veto, the Governor has shown that he does not believe in oversight or any level of accountability when it comes to policing.”

On social media, some were quick to point out errors in the press release about the veto, which had two different numbers for the bill and erroneously called the Arlington County Board the “Board of Supervisors.”

The hyper partisan @GovernorVA is so anxious to own the libs he vetoed a perfectly innocuous local control bill to bring transparency and accountability to policing and couldn’t be bothered to proofread it before putting it out pic.twitter.com/bumIaA6KGK

— Marcus Simon (@marcussimon) March 1, 2022

Glenn Youngkin must not have read the bill he just vetoed—Arlington County does not have a Board of Supervisors. pic.twitter.com/RPhpKSMqdY

— Matthew Savage (@MrMattSavage) March 1, 2022