News

Footage of Columbia Pike police shooting prompts calls to fix ‘institutional failures’

County leaders appear to be in an uphill battle trying to address community anger over a May police-involved shooting that killed a 33-year-old man along Columbia Pike.

Body-worn footage released last Friday was a “heavily edited, narrated theater piece designed to manufacture a narrative,” said Tia Alfred, one of several who voiced ongoing dissatisfaction at a town-hall meeting hosted by the County Board yesterday (Monday).

Alfred, who serves as first vice president of the Arlington NAACP but was speaking on her own behalf, voiced dissatisfaction both with the footage that was released, and with the months-long lag in making it public.

“These past five months, we’ve been trying to appeal to the conscience of leadership behind closed doors, but I’m standing here tonight because internal diplomacy is dead,” she told Board members. “We are dealing with deep, systemic institutional failures.”

Another speaker, Pamela Pinnock, joined calls for greater transparency and urgency.

“What the public received was a heavily edited video that did not provide the full context of what happened,” said Pinnock, who has been vocal in raising concerns about the shooting and aftermath.

Pinnock said she wants to see all footage, “not simply a version selected and edited by the police department,” and said County Manager Mark Schwartz must be held responsible for failings that have occurred.

“The county manager has failed to demonstrate the transparency, urgency and accountability this situation demands,” Pinnock said. “In my view, his handling of this matter represents a disregard for the Board’s responsibility to the public. I’m calling for his resignation or removal.”

Shawn Valn was shot and killed on May 8 after barricading himself inside a back room at a Columbia Pike convenience store. Police say he was brandishing a knife after officers breached the door.

A regional public-safety task force has been investigating the incident, and Commonwealth’s Attorney Parisa Dehghani-Tafti has convened a special grand jury to evaluate the episode.

In response to the ongoing concerns, several Board members at the Oct. 26 town hall acknowledged internal failures.

“The release of the video last Friday, I agree it was woefully delayed,” Board member Takis Karantonis said. “We are about to release a new policy that will avoid these kinds of delays in the future.”

Holding a public forum on the incident, which is being sought by some in the community, is “a reasonable request and we should plan for that,” Karantonis said.

Board member Julius “JD” Spain, Sr., who had been critical of delays in releasing the footage and attended the press conference where it was made public, said the experience had provided “a lot of lessons to be learned.”

“We should never have the community out there, waiting,” he said. “Transparency and accountability is not the same as prejudging and investigation.”

Board member Susan Cunningham also pointed to the pending release of the draft policy that will guide future responses to police-involved shootings.

“The policy draft that will be coming in the coming weeks for public comment back to the chief and the county manager is another piece, a down-payment toward more predictability going forward,” she said.

While saying that “Shawn Valn should be alive today,” Karantonis urged against judging the Arlington County Police Department with a broad brush, particularly as investigations are ongoing.

“Dozens of ACPD police women and men are right now out on the street protecting this community, doing everything they can, their very best, to, according to their mission, to the policies we put in place, to protect and sustain public safety in this community,” he said.

But Pinnock said it was already clear that police response during the May 8 incident was heavy-handed.

“He was a human being experiencing emotional distress. At least one officer on the scene knew him and knew him to be nonviolent,” she said. “Noncompliance should not result in a death sentence.”

About the Author

  • Scott McCaffrey

    A Northern Virginia native, Scott McCaffrey has four decades of reporting, editing and newsroom experience in the local area plus Florida, South Carolina and the eastern panhandle of West Virginia. He spent 26 years as editor of the Sun Gazette newspaper chain. For Local News Now, he covers government and civic issues in Arlington, Fairfax County and Falls Church.