A former Washington-Liberty High School substitute teacher will spend five years behind bars over an inappropriate relationship with a student that began when she was 16.
Timothy McGhee was sentenced today (Friday) in Arlington County Circuit Court, the Arlington County Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office said in a press release. After his release, he’ll serve three years of supervised probation with electronic monitoring.
McGhee must also register as a sex offender, complete sex offender treatment, have no contact with minors and stay away from places where children are present, prosecutors said.
“The trust placed in teachers and school employees is profound,” said Commonwealth’s Attorney Parisa Dehghani-Tafti. “When an adult entrusted with the care and education of a young person exploits that position of authority, it causes lasting harm and undermines the safety students deserve. I am grateful to the victim for her courage throughout this process and to the investigators and prosecutors who worked diligently to hold the defendant accountable.”
An Arlington jury found McGhee guilty of taking indecent liberties with a minor as a custodian or supervisor on Aug. 5, after a three-day trial. His first trial, last December, ended in a mistrial when jurors deadlocked 8-4.
McGhee met the student in 2022 while working as her long-term substitute teacher at W-L.
“He later became the student’s private math tutor, and the relationship continued for approximately two years, involving frequent contact both during and outside of school,” prosecutors said in a press release.
Court documents described sexual encounters in McGhee’s car and at the teen’s Arlington home, along with a trip to Chicago when she was 17. She ended the relationship in December 2024, shortly after turning 18, and police arrested McGhee the following month.
McGhee previously worked at local churches and unsuccessfully ran for state Senate as a Republican in 2011.