
This sponsored column is by Law Office of James Montana PLLC. All questions about it should be directed to James Montana, Esq., Janice Chen, Esq., and Victoria Khaydar, Esq., practicing attorneys at The Law Office of James Montana PLLC, an immigration-focused law firm located in Falls Church, Virginia. The legal information given here is general in nature. If you want legal advice, contact us for an appointment.
If you want a visa to come to the United States, you fill out the application, you pay the fee, you wait for an appointment, and you sit for an interview with a consular officer at a U.S. embassy or consulate. There are narrow exceptions. Being a friend of the President is not one of them.
Or it didn’t use to be.
On October 25, Brazilian Senator Flávio Bolsonaro – eldest son of the imprisoned former president Jair Bolsonaro – lost Brazil’s presidential runoff to Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, reportedly by more than 4.4 million votes. The next day, Brazil’s Supreme Court ordered him to surrender his passports as part of a money-laundering investigation. He did not. On Tuesday, a senior State Department official announced that Bolsonaro and his family would be granted U.S. visas. On Wednesday morning, he landed by private jet at Miami-Opa Locka Executive Airport.
We doubt very much that Senator Bolsonaro sat for a visa interview at the U.S. Embassy in Brasília, or at any of the U.S. consulates in Brazil, sometime between Monday’s court order and Tuesday’s departure. (And if he already held a valid visa, there was nothing for the State Department to announce.) So what, exactly, happened? Let’s consider the possibilities.
He was paroled. The Secretary of Homeland Security may parole a person into the United States “on a case-by-case basis for urgent humanitarian reasons or significant public benefit.” INA § 212(d)(5)(A). If that is what happened, it would at least be lawful. But we doubt that, too. An ordinary person who asks for parole files Form I-131 with USCIS and, in our experience, waits more than two years for a decision. Merely asking USCIS to expedite the application takes more than a month to get an answer, and the answer is routinely no. Senator Bolsonaro, it seems, got his overnight. If he was paroled, say so, and explain how he got to the front of the line.
The visa requirement was waived for an “unforeseen emergency.” The regulations do allow this. 8 C.F.R. § 212.1(g). But losing an election you have been campaigning in for a year is not unforeseen. Neither is a court order in an investigation you have known about for months. Indeed, Bolsonaro’s younger brother, Eduardo, said on a podcast earlier this month that Flávio should leave the country if he lost. Some emergency.
A visa will be issued after the fact. That isn’t how visas work. A visa is permission to travel to a port of entry and request admittance. Issuing one to a man who is already in Miami is like issuing a fishing license to a poacher with prize tarpon already gaffed and flopping on the deck.
The State Department spokesman doesn’t know the technical definition of a visa. A year ago, I would have called this a trollish hypothetical. It is less trollish now. The State Department laid off nearly 1,350 employees last summer, and is now scrambling to rehire for many of the same jobs. Institutional knowledge doesn’t grow back on demand.
Does Bolsonaro have a legitimate fear of persecution? Could he apply for asylum?
Maybe!
President Lula, celebrating his 81st birthday, offered his view of the matter: “A person who sneaks out of their country must have something to hide.” That is not how we would like a head of state to talk about a defeated opponent who is under criminal investigation. Flight is not proof of guilt, and a president who announces otherwise is handing a gift to any asylum lawyer who wants it.
There is more. Bolsonaro’s father is serving a 27-year sentence for leading a coup attempt. His brother Eduardo was convicted in absentia in June for lobbying the Trump administration. Now, prosecution is not persecution. Countries are allowed to investigate money laundering, including when the suspect is a senator. But prosecution can be a pretext for persecution, and whether it is one here is a question of fact. Questions of fact are what courts are for.
Eduardo, by the way, did not need a court. In July, he received a green card under the EB-1A category – the one reserved for people of “extraordinary ability.” Extraordinary, indeed.
Can Bolsonaro win asylum here?
Under current Board of Immigration Appeals precedent, probably not. On October 9, the Board decided Matter of B-S-A-N-, 30 I&N Dec. 145 (BIA 2026). Here is its second holding. (Our highlights are in bold.)
European Union citizens are presumptively ineligible for a discretionary grant of asylum in the United States because they are entitled to indefinitely reside lawfully in any EU member state.
Senator Bolsonaro, whose family descends from Italian immigrants, holds an Italian passport. Italy is in the European Union. Under B-S-A-N-, that should be the end of the matter.
We think B-S-A-N- is wrongly decided. The statute says that any alien physically present in the United States may apply for asylum. INA § 208(a)(1). Congress already wrote a rule for people who could be safe somewhere else: they can be sent to a safe third country under a bilateral or multilateral agreement. INA § 208(a)(2)(A). The Board has written its own rule instead, and it brushed aside contrary Ninth Circuit precedent, Lapadat v. Bondi, 145 F.4th 942 (9th Cir. 2025), in a footnote.
But read the next sentence of the decision:
This presumption may be overcome based on national security or foreign policy considerations.
Foreign policy is set by the President. So the rule, as written, is this: EU citizens don’t get asylum in the United States, unless the President would like them to. That’s how a bill becomes a law, kids!
The Board is no longer in a position to defy the President, if indeed it ever was. The administration cut the Board from 28 appellate judges to 15 and filled the remaining seats with its own appointees. Last year, DHS won 97% of the Board’s publicly posted cases. Does anyone doubt that if the Trump administration wants the immigration courts to grant Flávio Bolsonaro asylum, they will?
The law for everyone else
Here is the problem. An ordinary Gabonese citizen who used to hold a French passport will be denied asylum at her master calendar hearing, without trial. An ordinary Brazilian who wants to visit her sister in Arlington will wait for an interview, answer questions under oath, and be refused if the consular officer doubts she’ll go home. Those are the rules, and we explain them to clients every day.
A rule that bends for the right people is not a rule. It is a favor. The government has broad power over who enters this country, and rightly so, but that power is supposed to be exercised according to law – the same law, for everyone. When a defeated candidate flees a court order on a private jet and the State Department announces that he will receive (or will retroactively have received!) a visa because he’s Very Special, the message to everyone else is plain: the law’s blandishments apply to those with friends in power; the law’s punishments apply to everyone else.
Our advice to our clients remains the same. Apply in the ordinary way. Respect the government’s request. Show up to your interview.
Our advice to the government differs somewhat. Our government should either treat ordinary, law-abiding immigrants with the same consideration that they showed Flávio Bolsonaro, or treat Flávio Bolsonaro with the same insouciant indifference that ordinary, law-abiding immigrants routinely get.
As always, we are happy to answer questions from readers as best we can.