Submit Content

Statutes of Liberty: No One Gets In — Coronavirus Authority Used to Exclude Asylum Seekers at the U.S. Border

This sponsored column is by James Montana, Esq. and Doran Shemin, Esq., practicing attorneys at Steelyard LLC, an immigration-focused law firm located in Arlington, Virginia. The legal information given here is general in nature. If you want legal advice, contact James for an appointment.

For the Trump Administration, asylum claims at the border are a problem. Title 42 is the new solution.

What’s the problem? When an asylum seeker arrives at the border and claims that she is fleeing persecution, she has the right, under U.S. law, to have her claims heard before a fair and impartial adjudicator. Unfortunately, the United States lacks the ability to house asylum seekers in decent conditions for the amount of time that this adjudication requires.

Therefore, asylum seekers are routinely released into the interior of the United States to have their claims heard at other Immigration Courts — including our own local Immigration Court in Crystal City.

What’s the solution? Title 42, United States Code. Title 42 empowers the President to take actions to protect public health, and, under color of Title 42, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) is expelling immigrants on the basis of the COVID-19 pandemic. Attorneys like ourselves are calling these proceedings Title 42 proceedings to distinguish them from ordinary immigration proceedings under Title 8.

Beginning on March 21, 2020, the Trump Administration invoked its powers under Title 42 to expel immigrants who arrive at U.S. land borders, arguing that allowing immigrants to enter through the U.S. border increases the risk of introducing more COVID-19 cases into the United States.

According to CBP, “persons subject to the order… will be immediately expelled to their country of last transit. In the event a person cannot be returned to the country of last transit, CBP works with interagency partners to secure expulsion to the person’s country of origin and hold the person for the shortest time possible.” Some sources say that the expulsion procedure takes an average of 96 minutes.

CBP claims that there will be exceptions for humanitarian reasons. However, based on our recent experience with this relatively unknown procedure, we learned firsthand that CBP may not be properly taking humanitarian factors into consideration when determining whether to expel a person at the border.

Just a couple of weeks ago, our office learned that CBP had detained two unaccompanied minors in Texas. These children did everything they were supposed to do — they did not sign any documents allowing for their return to their country, they expressed that they were afraid to return to their country, and asked to speak with an asylum officer.

However, the immigration authorities did not listen and said that unless they got a lawyer, they would be put on a plane and sent back to their country. They were also not allowed to tell their family members where they were.

Our office stepped in to try to save these children from being expelled. Sadly, it took our office’s intervention and insistence that these children feared persecution and torture in their home country to convince CBP to take these children out of Title 42 proceedings and place them into regular immigration proceedings.

Unfortunately, this seems par for the course. Some of our readers may have read about ICE detaining children at a hotel in McAllen, Texas. It took a lawsuit to get these children out of the hotel and into regular immigration proceedings.

Many advocates believe that these Title 42 proceedings are illegal and violate our obligations under international human rights treaties, which Congress and Presidents past also enacted into U.S. law. On August 14, 2020, various nonprofit organizations sued the Trump Administration over these Title 42 proceedings, arguing that these proceedings violate various laws and deny asylum seekers a meaningful opportunity to apply for asylum in the United States.

The legality of these proceedings is in dispute. Our experience suggests that the Trump Administration knows that it is taking an aggressive approach which will be hard to defend in court. It is a bedrock principle of American law that the identity of the speaker does not matter. A pro se litigant’s request for asylum should not be ignored simply because she does not have a lawyer.

Our clients were ignored until we intervened. CBP’s response to unrepresented immigrants violates the right to due process enjoyed by all litigants in our legal system, whether represented or pro se.

This is a topic we will follow closely and we will report back with updates. We welcome your thoughts and comments and will do our best to respond.

Recent Stories

(Updated at 7:55 a.m.) Ireland’s Four Courts in Courthouse caught fire after a car barreled into it at the height of dinnertime Friday. The fire is now out after a…

After a steamy stretch, Mother Nature is rewarding us with a pair of new-perfect days. We hope you are able to get out there and enjoy the weather tonight and…

Adoptable Pet of the Week: Kimchi

The adorable Kimchi, a black and white Guinea Pig is the newest Adoptable Pet of the Week.

Open Houses includes a 1 BD/1 BA condo with an open floorplan and granite countertops listed at $350,000.

Do you struggle with anxiety, depression, stress, grief, trauma or anger? Are
you ready to make a change?

Lauren K. Nickum, LCSW, CSAC from Peaceful Mind Solutions is now taking new
clients for psychotherapy. Lauren has over 10 years of experience treating
mental health disorders and general life stress in adults and adolescents. For
more information visit

Submit your own Community Post here.

(This Community Post was written by Signature Theatre and underwritten by Embracing Arlington Arts.)

Signature Theatre just released single tickets for all 33rd season productions, which highlights the organization’s long-time relationship with legendary composer Stephen Sondheim. Beginning with the musical adaptation of The Color Purple and irreverent No Place to Go, the season continues with three Sondheim musicals, the DC premieres of Off-Broadway hit Which Way to the Stage and Pulitzer Prize finalist Selling Kabul, the Tony Award®-winning rock musical Passing Strange, and return of Signature’s cabaret series honoring legendary artists.

“Last November, the world lost an icon. The death of Stephen Sondheim was a blow to everyone in the theater community. Signature Theatre would not be the same without Sondheim — he IS Signature’s ‘signature.’ This season, we are honoring the legend with productions of Into the Woods, Pacific Overtures and Sweeney Todd dedicated to his memory. These shows represent the diversity and range of Sondheim,” said Signature’s Artistic Director Matthew Gardiner about the new season.

Read More

Submit your own Community Post here.

Azure Dream Day Spa Grand Opening

Azure Dream Day Spa is hosting their Grand Opening Celebration at their beautiful new spa located at 901 N. Quincy St. on Friday, August 12 from 5-9 p.m.

All are invited to come tour the new spa and to take

Running & Strength Training Group Workout #1

Join our first workout of Coach Kate’s fall Running & Strength Training Program on Tuesday, August 30 at 6:30 a.m. at Oak Grove Park.

First/trial session is Free Of Charge. If you would like to join the program — which


Subscribe to our mailing list