This sponsored column is by James Montana, Esq., Doran Shemin, Esq. and Laura Lorenzo, Esq., practicing attorneys at Steelyard LLC, an immigration-focused law firm located in Arlington, Virginia. The legal information given here is general in nature. If you want legal advice, contact James for an appointment.
The Biden Administration has proposed a major reform to the U.S. asylum system. As always, here at Statutes of Liberty, we’re here to give you both sides of the question.
What’s the problem?
The problem has three parts:
- The U.S. Immigration Courts have a backlog of 1.3 million (million!) cases, approximately half of which are asylum claims. There are approximately 500 immigration judges, so the backlog is 2,600 cases per judge. (You have to do some math to see how truly awful that is. Let’s assume that a case takes eight hours of work to adjudicate. That’s 20,800 hours of work, per judge, to clear the backlog. There are 2,000 work hours per year. So, with the current IJ corps and the current backlog, it will take ten years to get to zero… assuming that no new cases come in the door.)
- Asylum applicants who seek asylum at the U.S. border are automatically referred to the U.S. Immigration Courts after passing a “credible fear interview.” This is a major source of input for new cases coming into the immigration courts.
- The U.S. maintains a parallel asylum adjudication system outside the Immigration Courts at Asylum Offices, which are staffed by asylum officers rather than judges. The backlog at asylum offices is bad — quite bad — but it isn’t close to as bad as at the immigration courts.
What’s the solution?
Faced with this Brobdingnagian backlog, the Biden Administration has proposed a new regulation that will grant additional powers to asylum officers and shift some cases from the Immigration Courts to the Asylum Offices. The cases in question are border asylum claims only. People who enter the United States with a visa, and then request asylum, would see no changes.
Currently, asylum officers only have two choices: Grant asylum or refer the case to an immigration judge for review. Review by the immigration judge is what lawyers call de novo review. In plain English, the immigration judge does the entire case over again, from scratch, without relying on the prior work done by the asylum officer.
Under the new regulation, asylum officers would be empowered to do a fuller review of border cases and have more choices about how to dispose of cases. These super-officers would be able to grant asylum, grant withholding of removal, grant protection under the Convention Against Torture, or refer the cases to the immigration courts for further review. Although the proposed rule says that the immigration courts would review the cases de novo, the proposed rule also says that the courts would rule “based on the record of the hearing before the Asylum Office plus any additional, non-duplicative evidence presented to the court that is necessary to reach a reasoned decision.” Note that asylum officers are, generally, non-lawyers, and so immigration judges would be conducting, in effect, appellate review of quasi-judicial decisions crafted by laymen.
What would the practical effects of this process be?
Much depends on the details. For example, if immigration judges conduct only rubber-stamp review of asylum officers’ decisions, many applicants are likely to be denied asylum under U.S. law without the reasoned judicial review required, in our view, by the Constitution. On the other hand, if the immigration judges conduct full fact-finding in referred cases, it’s difficult to see how the change will ameliorate the backlog problem — it would simply postpone it by shunting border asylum claims into the asylum offices pre-referral to the immigration courts.
As always, we welcome any thoughts or comments and will do our best to respond.
Meeting for lunch? Starting Monday, January 30 and running until Friday, February 3, Copperwood Tavern, The Pinemoor, and Brass Rabbit Pub will be offering buy one, get one free soups, salads, sandwiches, and…
Work is ramping up on a new Arlington County bus maintenance building and parking garage in Green Valley. Crews are set to wrap up laying the foundation for the Arlington Transit…
If you’re not one of the many proudly sporting a Gondola Now shirt around town, you’re missing out on a high quality piece of apparel that starts lots of interesting…
The Old Bike Shop in Lyon Park is closing next month after a decade in business. Owner Lawrence Behery told ARLnow that he’s shuttering the used bike repair and sales…
St. Charles offers a play-based curriculum in a welcoming, Christ-centered environment.
Our program focuses on socio-emotional development and kindergarten readiness through hands-on and engaging activities. Our programs offer different schedules ranging from 7:30 am-5:30 pm for students, ages 2-5. We feature a full-day Jr. kindergarten class for older 4’s/5’s. Our facility includes a full-sized gymnasium, school chapel, and library. All of our students enjoy music and physical education weekly. Children have an opportunity to participate in enrichment classes such as soccer, basketball, ballet, and science.
We offer Summer Camp with weekly themes and twice a week water play, including Fun Friday moon bounce. Please join us for our Open House Feb. 3 at 9:30 am and 11:00 am. Click here to sign-up.
For more information or to schedule a tour, visit us at www.stcharlesarlington.org or call (703) 527-0608.
If you are a lifelong learner over 50+ who wants to make new friends, power up your brain, and enjoy a wide-variety college-level courses, Encore Learning is for you. An Arlington based nonprofit, Encore Learning offers courses in the arts, theater, literature, history, technology and more. This semester we offer our most popular course, Global Hot Spots as well as 25 new courses. Courses are presented either online or in-person at George Mason University at Virginia Square and other Arlington locations.
Join the free presentation to learn about courses and meet the instructors. This is Encore Learning’s signature event to highlight the upcoming semester with brief presentations by each instructor.
The Spring Course Preview event is Thursday, February 2nd at 9:30 AM via Zoom:
The truth, your first pregnancy and new mom months are full of twists and turns, ups and downs, and lots of questions! None of us really know the best way to do it – we just figure it out, together…