Join Club

Parent committee urges APS to require student cell phones to be off and away for the day

People on smartphones (staff photo by Jay Westcott)

Should Arlington Public Schools keep students from using their phones in schools?

The School Health Advisory Board — a committee of parents, some of whom are nurses and doctors, and a few administrators — has recommended APS adopt a policy for the next school year requiring smartphones to be off and put away during school hours.

This group has been advocating for a system-wide phone policy since 2019 but today, principals and teachers are following this policy on a school-by-school and classroom-by-classroom basis. Kenmore, Dorothy Hamm and Swanson and middle schools have these phone policies in place, says APS spokesman Frank Bellavia.

There, students are not allowed to have their cell phones out in school unless for very specific instructional purposes, he says. Phones are not allowed during passing time or in the cafeteria, too.

This ad-hoc approach “makes it difficult to enforce for both teachers and principles,” committee chair Desiree Jarowski told the School Board during a work session this January, advocating for a system-wide policy.

“It creates more problems for the students because there is no consistency in policy, and no consequences if they don’t follow the rules — particularly if the teacher is the one requesting the student puts the cell phone or other device away,” she asserted.

Jarowski described instances of students cheating with their cell phones and refusing to put away their phones when teachers asked. She said that SHAB has heard from “many parents” concerned about cell phones use in schools, while an informal survey of parents on the Arlington Education Matters Facebook page showed some 88% of respondents would want “away for the day” policies at all secondary schools.

A parent of a Swanson Middle School student tells ARLnow that despite the policy, his son has observed kids use their phones in the hallways and during class to play music, watch videos, play games and look at dating apps.

SHAB is urging APS to adopt a draft policy it created in 2019. Doing so, Bellavia says, would have to follow the usual APS process for policy development, including drafts being written and shared with stakeholder groups and made available for public comment.

If APS agreed to draft such a policy, it would follow the lead of Fairfax County Public Schools. Last summer, it updated the student conduct guidelines to say phones have to be silenced and put away for the duration of the school day for elementary and middle schoolers and during instructional periods for high schoolers, “to help foster a learning environment that is conducive to learning.”

This change came after Herndon High School cracked down on record-high phone use last spring with some positive results.

Current APS policies stipulate when and how kids can use their phones and ways schools can teach them proper phone use.

“APS is committed to assisting students and staff members in creating a 21st century learning environment,” the APS student handbook says. “To support this progress, with classroom teacher approval, students may use their personal devices smartphones, laptops, netbooks, tablets, etc.) to access the Internet and collaborate with other students during the school day.”

It has an acceptable use policy that stipulates, among other things, a digital citizenship curriculum “educating students about appropriate online behavior, including interacting with students and other individuals on social network sites, public websites, blogs, and other electronic communication tools.”

Reactions among School Board members to the idea of a system-wide policy were mixed.

School Board Vice-Chair Cristina Diaz-Torres strongly opposed it. She said the draft policy is concerning and based on research with disputable sample sizes, while enforcement would eat into instructional time.

“What I would strongly consider that we do is really double down on our efforts to encourage our students to use these devices responsibly,” she said.

“There’s no version of the world where cellphones are ever going to go away,” she continued. “In the same way we’re teaching our students to self-regulate emotionally, as one board member, I would strongly encourage instead that we be leaning into ways to teach our students to self-regulate, to self-moderate, to really understand the utility of the tool, and use it in appropriate moments.”

Jarowski, however, was less optimistic about self regulation.

“I think it’s hard to put them away, and the kids use them constantly as a means of social interaction,” she said. “Take a child, who’s 15, 14, even 17-18: Their brains are way under-developed to handle the addiction that a lot of them feel.”

School Board Chair Reid Goldstein suggested specific circumstances need to be thought through before a sweeping change like this is made, such as ensuring parents can communicate with their children on days they need to leave school for an appointment.

School Board Member Mary Kadera said Jarowski’s argument resonated with what her sons in APS have told her they see in their classes. She suggested to “fine-tune” this recommendation by creating a designated phone-use area in school buildings where students can check a message.

“If I need to know whether my doctor’s appointment got rescheduled, it seems to me that if there were a place that a student could go, there’d be a measure of flexibility that would make it less onerous to families and students themselves,” she said.

Some 77% of school districts banned non-academic phone use during the 2019-20 school year, compared to 66% during the 2015-16 school year and 90% in the early 2010s, according to the National Center for Education Statistics.

And screen time is even higher in the years since the pandemic, up 52%, according to one study.

Some studies show that the presence of smartphones reduces cognitive abilities, while active phone use during lectures results in a lower quality and quantity of notes, poorer ability to recall information and lower test scores, especially compared to people taking pen-and-paper notes.

As for social-emotional impacts, some evidence connects screen time from infancy to four years old, such as iPad use, with poorer executive functioning and emotional regulation once children were 8-9 years old. It also connects smartphone use with less enjoyment of face-to-face interactions.

Much of the screen time literature, however, conflates passive (think: TV), active (think: video games), and educational (think: assisting with homework) use, throwing into question the findings, per a review of available literature in 2019 commissioned by APS.

One study found the effects of screen time may be moderated by the type of screen time and another suggests that screens are not inherently harmful — with children only marginally more likely to have attention disorders, disturbed sleep or lower grades and no more likely to suffer from depression and anxiety. Meanwhile, phones can actually be good for deepening friendships, the study suggests.

Recent Stories

Good Friday evening, Arlington. Let’s take a look back at today’s stories and a look forward to tomorrow’s event calendar. đź•— News recap The following articles were published earlier today…

An explosives detection K-9 celebrated his retirement at Reagan National Airport today. Messi, an 8-year-old yellow lab, was feted this morning in the historic Terminal 1 lobby with a surprise…

Walk to Lee Heights shops from 1930s Tudor on beautiful terraced lot

Arlington’s response team for people in mental health and substance use crises is on track for a substantial buildout. An additional $478,286 in federal funds would allow Arlington to hire…

The Award is available to recent high school graduates and non-traditional students (see the application for more details). Each recipient may be awarded up to $20,000. Applicants are required to submit an online application form as well as a short video application.

The applicant must be an Arlington resident pursuing a career or technical education accredited program, within a high-growth career, that will be completed within two years.

The careers and programs include, but are not limited to:

  • Audio, Video, and Sound Engineering Technicians

  • Broadcast Technicians

  • Commercial Drivers

  • Culinary Arts

  • Early Childcare Education

  • Healthcare

  • Information Technology and Computer Science

  • Manufacturing and Skilled Trades (including welding, auto and aviation mechanics and technicians)

  • Public Safety

Read More

Submit your own Announcement here.

ACFCU’s Free Homebuying 101 Webinar: Steps to Getting Pre-Approved

Are you ready to jump into homeownership, or have you started considering it but don’t know where to start?

Financial preparation is key when thinking about purchasing your first home and the first step to getting pre-approved. Join ACFCU for

Sweeney Todd

A victim of a gross injustice that robbed him of his wife and child, Sweeney Todd sets about exacting a terrible revenge on society.

Ă—

Subscribe to our mailing list