News

Arlington could set higher bar for sending historic district proposals to County Board

Revised rules for designating local historic districts in Arlington could create a more selective process for sending recommendations to the County Board.

County Board members over the summer approved a staff request to study the existing process for designating historic districts and propose potential changes.

While the process is not yet underway, it appears one of the key questions will be whether to increase the number of specific criteria that need to be met before the Historical Affairs and Landmark Review Board (HALRB) can direct staff to study a property’s historic provenance.

The HALRB on Oct. 21 received an informal staff briefing on how potential revisions to the historic-designation process will be considered, and when the advisory panel as well as the public and preservation advocates will have input.

Currently, a property needs to meet a minimum of two of the 11 established criteria in order to move forward in the evaluation process:

  • The property is listed or is eligible for inclusion in the National Register of Historic Places
  • The property has character, interest or value as part of the development, heritage or cultural characteristics of the county, state or nation
  • The property was the site of a significant local, state or national event
  • The property is associated with a person or persons who significantly contributed to the development of the county, state or nation
  • The property embodies distinguishing characteristics of an architectural style valuable for the study of a period, type or method of construction
  • The property is identified as the work of a master builder, architect or landscape architect
  • The property embodies elements of design, detailing, materials, or craftsmanship that render it structurally or architecturally significant
  • The property has a distinctive location or singular physical characteristics that make it an established or familiar visual feature
  • The property is a particularly fine or unique example of a utilitarian structure representing a period or style in the commercial, industrial or agricultural development of the county, with a high level of historic integrity or architectural significance
  • The property has the potential to yield information important to the prehistory or history of the county, state or nation
  • The property is suitable for preservation or restoration

The small number of criteria that must be met, and the broad scope of some of the categories, put the odds in favor of a site succeeding in winning an HALRB vote directing staff to review the site. But, historic-preservation staff appear to believe, the minimal number of criteria may also lead to a property going to the County Board for final action without strong reasons to validate its historic status.

At the Oct. 21 meeting, HALRB member and former chair Richard Woodruff pressed staff to confirm whether the process of reviewing current requirements and recommending changes would occur in ways that interested parties could follow.

“I would request that this could be done in a way we can all have full visibility,” he said. “So that it’s not done before we have a chance to really weigh in.”

Because the process to create new historic districts is embedded in the county’s zoning ordinance, any revisions would require public hearings and likely would have to progress through several advisory panels before County Board members could enact them.

Unlike designations on the National Register of Historic Places and Virginia Landmarks Register, which are merely honorific, designation as a local historic district in Arlington puts restrictions on property owners about exterior use and potential redevelopment.

In recent years, County Board members have been skittish about considering historic designations on properties where owners are opposed.

That was the case in two recent high-profile preservation battles, one over the Febrey-Lothrop mansion on Wilson Blvd and the other on the Melwood property in Aurora Highlands.

Also discussed at the briefing was the potential to add designations like “cultural heritage districts” that might have some protections, but not those of full-blown historic districts.

About the Author

  • Scott McCaffrey

    A Northern Virginia native, Scott McCaffrey has four decades of reporting, editing and newsroom experience in the local area plus Florida, South Carolina and the eastern panhandle of West Virginia. He spent 26 years as editor of the Sun Gazette newspaper chain. For Local News Now, he covers government and civic issues in Arlington, Fairfax County and Falls Church.