The future of housing in Arlington was among the issues taking center stage at a town hall hosted by the County Board on Monday night.
Opinions were varied and without consensus, with some promoting looser zoning restrictions and others contending the county’s signature housing policy is counterproductive.
“We need to stop the madness on that and do something different,” said Richard McNamara, who has been a vocal critic of the county’s Expanded Housing Options (EHO), better known as Missing Middle.
“Your EHO program has only made things worse — alienating neighbors against neighbors as well as taking affordable homes, the $750,000 to $850,000 range, and replacing them with $1.6 million duplexes,” he said.
Opponents of the County Board’s embrace of Missing Middle seemed to be outnumbered at the two-hour forum by speakers pushing for more housing choice throughout the community.
“We all deserve to live and work in the same place,” said Rev. C.J. Valenti of Faith Lutheran Church. “I want that same access for everyone.”
“We need bold policies to grow our housing supply,” said Jane Green. “We are governed by a 60-year-old mindset that will not let us meet the needs of the 21st century.”
“Density is magic,” Green said. “It lets us combine our resources to share high land value — there is enough [space] for everyone.”
Others still had concerns. Among them was Kathy Sibert, who for years served as executive director of the Arlington Street People’s Assistance Network (now PathForward). She told Board members that Missing Middle had been sold to county residents as a way to bring more modestly priced housing options to the community.
“Where is the ‘affordable’ in the Missing Middle? It’s not there,” she said. “You’ve had three or four years and the results are pretty damning. You need to stop.”
“This was supposed to be housing for our school teachers, it was to be housing for our firefighters, for our middle-class people, and it’s not that,” Sibert said. “We’re increasing density … but that wasn’t where [Missing Middle] originated.”
Joshua Handler, who has vocally opposed Missing Middle/EHO, noted that, according to county data, Arlington has around 120,000 households and a housing stock of around 126,000 units.
“Our crisis isn’t a shortage of total housing,” he said, pointing instead to a “lack of homes for low-income households.”
Others suggested that increasing housing availability would help to lower costs in the long run. Arlington needs “plentiful housing of all types,” advocate Pat Findikoglu said.
“I’m not alone in wanting to share my good luck” in living in the community, she said.
County Board members, who have made broadening housing supply one of their key collective tenets, said they appreciated hearing from all sides on the issue.
“I take every testimony seriously,” Board member Julius “JD” Spain, Sr., said. “The question becomes, what kind of Arlington, at the end of the day, are we trying to build?”
County Board Chair Matt de Ferranti also said he appreciated those who came to speak on housing matters.
“There were so many that were strong,” he said of the comments.
The Oct. 26 community town hall was the second and final one of the year. County Board members inaugurated the initiative following complaints about a lack of venues for the public to express views on a wide array of public-policy matters and site-specific concerns.